Just read the TAX Office overview of the latest budget out of Australia.
I am very ashamed to be an Australian today and very glad to be far far away from the men who are running my homeland.
Where do I start?
The tax cuts are worth $37 billion dollars?
Did you know that we provide less then 1/12 of the Tax cut (about $3 billion) to overseas aid and development each year. I’d love the government to give me a smaller tax cut to fulfil our commitment (which I believe is rather theoretical) to the MDG’s.
I had a look through the overseas development and assistance budget and as far as I can see it’s a lot less then it would seem. They have put in all kinds of things that don’t belong there.
We start off with a budgeted figure of $2946.3 million for 2006/2007 budget year.
We are kindly giving Iraq $334 million in debt relief. Wonder how this compares to the cost of the military invasion of Iraq we supported. Or how it compares to the value of the infrastructure we helped destroy. The total $357 million being spent on Iraq should be moved to the Department Of Defence. So that’s 12% gone there. Leaving us with $2589.3 billion.
By the same reasoning I take out Afghanistan’s 33.9 million another 0.9% of the budget disappears and it’s $2555.4 million.
Ok now lets go through and remove some of the one offs. We are giving $136.2 million as a once off for debt relief. Which is 5% of the budget. That brings it down to $2419.2 million. I’ll keep Tsunmi AID as another disaster will come soon enough.
I am going to leave it to you to decide if the AusAid Governance programs are worthwhile, they do take up 26% of our ODA budget. That is $766.04 million, now most of this money we spend on things in our best interest like economic management at 25%. To me it’s like a bank giving you financial planning so you can pay back your loans. Most of the advice we give I am sure is in our own best interests. I am going to be kind to the government and just take out that. So that’s another $191.51 million that doesn’t belong in this budget. Bringing my revised budget figure to $2227.69 million.
I could go on but I think you might be getting my point.
But one more thing I want to talk about is that these millions dollars I am talking about could be saving lives. It doesn’t cost much to feed a person, or to provide a person with a treatment to cure TB. Everyday people die because we do too little.
I feel depressed, and disappointed. I can’t help but feel like Make Poverty History and the MDG’s are going to fail, with countries like Australia not giving what they promised at the UN. I am wondering whether it is time to move beyond nation states and their broken promises and commitments. I am wondering if we as individuals can be selfless, disciplined and charismatic enough to raise the money that is needed ourselves. I don’t know how it would work. Could I give up some luxuries in an attempt to halve extreme poverty?
I am talking about raising billions of dollars here, the kind of money that multi-nationals and governments have and some rather wealthy individual.
References:
AusAid Budget information
Budget Overview
And remember to checkout Bens blog over the coming days for a much better analysis then I have provided.
About stuff